top of page

CARRIERS

With access to several of the largest and most respected companies, we are confident we can find the best coverage and rates for you. Use the links below to see more information about a company. Some of the companies we represent offer online claims service and bill pay.

Auto-Owners Logo

Auto-Owners Insurance

Phone:

800.346.0346

Claims:

888.252.4626

American Modern Logo

American Modern

Phone:

855.469.2644

Claims:

800.375.2075

Arlington Roe & Company Logo

Arlington Roe & Company

Phone:

800.878.9891

Assurity Life Insurance Logo

Assurity Life Insurance

Phone:

800.869.0355 Ext. 4279

Claims:

800.869.0355 Ext. 4484

Cincinnati Insurance Logo

Cincinnati Insurance

Phone:

888.242.8811

Claims:

877.242.2544

Colonial Life Logo

Colonial Life

Phone:

800.325.4368

Claims:

800.880.9325

Foresters Financial Logo

Foresters Financial

Phone:

800.828.1540

Grange Insurance Logo

Grange Insurance

Phone:

800.422.0550

Claims:

800.445.3030

Kansas City Life Logo

Kansas City Life

Phone:

800.821.6164

Liberty Mutual Logo

Liberty Mutual Insurance

Phone:

844.629.8984

Claims:

800.225.2467

Medical Mutual Logo

Medical Mutual

Phone:

800.382.5729

Mutual of Omaha Logo

Mutual of Omaha

Phone:

800.228.7104

Nationwide Insurance Logo

Nationwide Insurance

Phone:

877.669.6877

Claims:

800.421.3535

Philadelphia Insurance Logo

Philadelphia Insurance Companies

Phone:

800.334.2370

Claims:

888.252.4626

Principal Financial Group

Principal Financial Group

Phone:

800.986.3343

Progressive Insurance Logo

Progressive Insurance

Phone:

888.671.4405

Claims:

800.776.4737

RT Specialty Logo

RT Specialty

Phone:

312.784.6001

Safeco Insurance Logo

Safeco Insurance

Phone:

800.332.3226

Claims:

800.332.3226

State Auto Logo

State Auto

Phone:

614.464.5000

Claims:

800.766.1853

The Hartford Logo

The Hartford

Phone:

860.547.5000

Claims:

800.243.5860

UnitedHealthcare Logo

UnitedHealthcare

Phone:

866.633.2446

Contact Us

Crotty & Associates, LLC
PO Box 3124
Dublin, Ohio 43016-0058
Phone: 614.889.4732
Fax: 614.889.6380

​

Hours of Operation:
Monday-Friday:

8:00am-5:00pm

Auto-Owners Logo_White.png

Name *

Phone *

Email *

Subject

Message

Thank you! Message sent.

©

2026

Crotty & Associates, LLC | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy

bottom of page